The National Rollout of the Child Focused Court | What Does It Mean for Families?

The National Rollout of the Child Focused Court | What Does It Mean for Families?

The Ministry of Justice has announced the national rollout of the Child Focussed Court (CFC) across England and Wales. The CFC comes into force in different geographical areas at different times. The CFC was previously part of a pilot within the Family Court and was known as the Pathfinder Pilot. The pilot began in February 2022, and it was reported to have reduced the timeframe of private law children cases by 7 months. The CFC is a significant reform to the way in which private law children cases are approached and the reasoning behind the reform is to place the safety, experiences and welfare of the children at the heart of the proceedings from the earliest possible stage.

The publication of the Ministry of Justice's Harm Panel Report highlighted the need for a family justice system that prioritised safety, reduced harm, and better understood children's lived experiences.

What is a Child Focused Court?

A CFC adopts a more investigative and problem-solving approach than the previous court model. Rather than relying on multiple hearings to gradually gather information, the new process seeks to obtain a fuller understanding of the child's circumstances at the earliest possible stage.

The model brings together a range of agencies, including:

  • The Court;
  • Cafcass or Cafcass Cymru;
  • Local authorities;
  • Domestic abuse specialists;
  • Other relevant professionals.

This multi-agency approach aims to ensure that concerns relating to abuse, neglect, coercive control, unresolved issues between the parents, and other welfare issues are identified and considered from the outset.

The Child Impact Report

One of the most significant developments is the introduction of the Child Impact Report.

This report is prepared early in proceedings and is designed to provide the Court with a comprehensive understanding of the child's experiences, wishes, feelings, and welfare needs. It enables decision-makers to focus on what the child is experiencing.

By gathering information at an earlier stage, it is hoped that the Court will be better placed to make informed decisions without the need for numerous interim hearings.

A key principle of the CFC model is that children should be heard wherever appropriate.

The approach recognises that children are directly affected by Family Court proceedings and that the Court must understand their lived experiences. Judges involved in the rollout have highlighted the importance of the voice of the child being heard and understanding the impact that family conflict may be having on them.

This does not mean children are expected to make decisions about where they live or who they spend time with. Instead, it ensures that their experiences and perspectives form an important part of the evidence considered by the Court.

The impact on domestic abuse cases

The CFC model has particular significance in cases involving allegations of domestic abuse.

By front-loading investigations and encouraging closer collaboration between agencies, the model seeks to identify risks earlier and reduce the possibility of survivors being re-traumatised through lengthy and repetitive Court processes. It also aims to improve the Court's understanding of the impact domestic abuse may have on both the adults and children involved.

For many practitioners working with survivors, this represents a welcome move towards a more trauma-informed family justice system.

Process

When an application has been issued, a judge or legal adviser will swiftly review the case at ‘Initial Gatekeeping’ to decide on the appropriate steps to take. There is then two stages: Stage 1: Information Gathering and Assessment and Stage 2: Interventions and/or Decision Hearing.

Stage 1

At stage 1, a CIR will be ordered in the majority of cases; this will be prepared by a Family Court Adviser (‘FCA’) from Cafcass if the case has been issued in England, or Cafcass Cymru in Wales; in certain circumstances (where the family has had recent contact with a local authority), the CIR will be prepared by a local authority social worker. The CIR will contain information garnered from multiple sources (i.e. safeguarding information, professional assessments, risk information, the views of parents and others involved, including the child where appropriate. Where domestic abuse is an issue in the case, a referral to an Independent Domestic Violence Adviser (IDVA) or Domestic Abuse Support Worker can be made.

The CIR should ordinarily be filed within eight weeks of the application; the CIR is designed to provide the judge at the first ‘Decision Hearing’ with a rounded picture of the child’s lived experience and, as the title of the report suggests, a description of the ‘impact’ in cases where an agreement between the parents cannot be reached.

Stage Two

The filing of the CIR will trigger the second stage which commences with a second gatekeeping review of the case. If a final decision is not made at this stage, further listing decisions will be made; this could be to list the applications for a Fact-Finding Hearing (if indicated) or for a Decision Hearing.

At a Decision Hearing, it is envisaged that the judge or magistrates will adopt investigative problem-solving strategies to attempt resolution of the family dispute. Judges and magistrates are expected to adopt a trauma-informed approach to issues of domestic abuse, focusing on how the arrangements sought will impact upon the child and the victim parent.

A party who alleges that they are a victim-survivor of domestic abuse may have the assistance of an IDVA at the hearing. The IDVA may also have provided a specialist assessment of risk to the adult and child to inform the court and aid the Court’s decision making in relation to the order being sought.

Conclusion

Whilst it remains to be seen whether the benefits reported during the Pathfinder Pilot can be replicated nationally, the early evidence is encouraging. For parents involved in proceedings, the process is intended to provide a clearer understanding of the issues affecting their child at an earlier stage and, where possible, support earlier resolution.

Ultimately, the success of the CFC will be measured not only by reduced timescales, but by whether children feel heard, protected and better supported throughout the family justice process.